Sep 10

Sep 10 10 Mystery Books For Teens

Getting teenagers to fall in love with reading can sometimes feel like a puzzle in itself. Not every teen is naturally drawn to books, especially with so many competing distractions vying for their attention. But mystery books can be a powerful way to spark curiosity and keep young readers turning pages late into the night. A teen mystery combines suspense, clever plots, and engaging characters that encourage even reluctant readers to keep going just to find out what happens next.

In this post, I’ve rounded up a collection of mystery books for teens that are entertaining, thought-provoking, and filled with twists and turns. Whether your teen is already a book lover or someone who struggles to find a story that holds their attention, these young adult mysteries might be the perfect gateway into the joy of reading.

10 Mystery Books For Teens

Before we dive into the book list, let’s take a closer look at what makes a great mystery book for teens. Not all mysteries are created equal, and when it comes to young adult readers, the best stories balance intrigue with relatable themes. By understanding what makes these novels so compelling, you’ll have an easier time choosing the right ones for your teen.

And if you’re looking for other age-appropriate options, you might also enjoy my roundup of the best mystery books for kids. For readers of all ages, I’ve also shared a list of the best mystery series books and even the best mystery romance books for those who love a mix of suspense and heart.

What Makes A Good Mystery Book for Teens

Relatable Protagonists

A strong teen mystery usually features a main character that young readers can relate to—whether that’s a high school student, a group of friends, or a character navigating the challenges of identity and belonging. These protagonists allow readers to see themselves in the story, even as they unravel complex clues.

Age-Appropriate Stakes

While adult mysteries might dive into gruesome crimes or psychological thrillers, a good young adult mystery balances suspense with stakes that feel real but not overwhelming. The danger might involve missing friends, hidden family secrets, or community scandals, which keeps the tension high without pushing past what’s appropriate for teen readers.

Clever Plot Twists

Mysteries thrive on surprises, and the best ones for teens deliver twists that feel both unexpected and satisfying. Teens enjoy the challenge of trying to solve the puzzle before the reveal, and a smart twist keeps them hooked until the final chapter.

Themes of Growth and Identity

Since young adult books often double as coming-of-age stories, a great mystery also weaves in themes of friendship, trust, love, and self-discovery. These elements add emotional depth and help teens connect with the story beyond the surface-level puzzle.

Page-Turning Suspense

Above all, mystery books for teens need to be entertaining. Shorter chapters, cliffhanger endings, and fast-paced plots all help keep teens engaged. The key is balancing excitement with meaningful storytelling.

Buy Books on Bookshop.org to Support Local Bookstores

Buy Books on Amazon

What Are The Best Mystery Books For Teens

A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder by Holly Jackson

This bestselling series starter is a favorite among young adult readers. It follows Pippa Fitz-Amobi, a student who decides to investigate a local murder that everyone believes was solved years ago. Holly Jackson masterfully combines suspense, modern teen life, and social commentary, making this a teen mystery that feels fresh and relevant. Expect twists you won’t see coming and a heroine who refuses to settle for easy answers.

One of Us Is Lying by Karen M. McManus

Karen M. McManus is often credited with reinvigorating the YA mystery genre, and this book shows why. When five students walk into detention and only four walk out alive, the survivors find themselves at the center of a murder investigation. Each has secrets, and the story plays out like a teen version of The Breakfast Club meets Pretty Little Liars. Teens love the blend of high school drama and edge-of-your-seat suspense.

Truly Devious by Maureen Johnson

Set in a prestigious boarding school in Vermont, this series introduces Stevie Bell, a teen obsessed with true crime who sets out to solve a decades-old kidnapping and murder. Maureen Johnson combines wit, clever puzzles, and unforgettable characters. Teens who love atmospheric settings and layered mysteries will find themselves fully immersed in Stevie’s world.

Sadie by Courtney Summers

Told through dual perspectives—a gripping podcast transcript and Sadie’s own journey—this book is as haunting as it is suspenseful. Sadie sets out to find her missing sister, only to become the subject of a nationwide podcast investigation. The format makes it feel modern and compelling, and it resonates strongly with fans of true-crime media. This mystery book doesn’t shy away from dark themes, making it perfect for older teens.

The Inheritance Games by Jennifer Lynn Barnes

This series has skyrocketed in popularity thanks to its blend of mystery, puzzles, and romance. When Avery Grambs unexpectedly inherits the fortune of a billionaire she’s never met, she’s thrust into a world of riddles, family drama, and high-stakes danger. Jennifer Lynn Barnes expertly balances suspense with humor and charm, making this a great choice for teens who enjoy mystery with a glamorous twist.

We Were Liars by E. Lockhart

Part mystery, part psychological drama, this novel explores themes of privilege, memory, and family secrets. Set on a private island, the story follows Cadence Sinclair as she pieces together what really happened during a fateful summer. The shocking ending is one of the most talked-about twists in young adult literature, ensuring it will stick with readers long after they finish.

Little Monsters by Kara Thomas

Kara Thomas is known for writing edgy, unputdownable young adult mysteries, and Little Monsters is a standout. It follows Kacey, a new girl in town who gets caught up in a local disappearance. The novel explores the darker sides of friendship and teen relationships while delivering a mystery filled with tension and psychological depth.

Monday’s Not Coming by Tiffany D. Jackson

Tiffany D. Jackson writes contemporary mysteries that are both gripping and socially powerful. This story follows Claudia as she searches for her missing best friend, Monday, whose disappearance no one else seems concerned about. Blending suspense with themes of race, neglect, and friendship, this novel challenges readers to think critically while staying glued to the page.

The Box in the Woods by Maureen Johnson

For fans of the Truly Devious series, this standalone companion brings Stevie Bell into a new mystery at a summer camp with a dark past. It’s the perfect blend of classic teen camp setting and spine-tingling suspense. Johnson keeps readers guessing while sprinkling in humor and relatable teen moments.

They Wish They Were Us by Jessica Goodman

This prep-school thriller combines secret societies, murder, and the pressures of elite academia. Jill Newman believes her friend’s killer has already been caught, but as her senior year begins, she realizes the truth might be far more complicated. Jessica Goodman writes with sharp insight into the pressures teens face, while also delivering a mystery full of suspense and glamour.

Final Thoughts on Teen Mystery Reads

Mystery books for teens are more than just page-turners—they’re opportunities for young readers to explore themes of trust, justice, and identity while enjoying a puzzle that keeps them engaged. From modern thrillers to atmospheric dramas, there’s something on this list for every type of reader.

Encouraging teens to dive into a good young adult mystery can be the first step toward a lifelong love of reading. Whether your teen prefers glamorous thrillers, psychological suspense, or cleverly plotted whodunits, the stories above promise plenty of late-night reading sessions under the covers.

This post contains affiliate links, which means I receive compensation if you make a purchase using this link. Thank you for supporting this blog and the books I recommend! I may have received a book for free in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own.

Hi.